Seth Rogen and the Eddie Murphy Dilemma

It was a rainy Friday night and I hadn’t spent the mortgage money on a feature film in a few weeks. The wife wasn’t feeling well and the boy was itching for something to do. The new DreamWorks joint Monsters vs. Aliens had just hit the screen. The solution seemed simple.

With nothing in the way of plot, good comedy, or overarching message to distract me, I found myself thinking about the character they called B.O.B. Voiced by America’s latest comedy obsession, Seth Rogen, B.O.B. is a gelatinous, brainless blob of a monster that occasionally likes to ingest mass quantities. It reminded me a lot of some of the characters Rogen tends to play. While there was no great competition in the movie for best character, I came away thinking B.O.B. was the funniest and most enjoyable. Later, I wondered why. I came up with one answer.

We Hollywood consumers have been conditioned to like and laugh at Rogen. It’s easy to do. He plays a character we like–hapless (Knocked Up), occasionally stoned (Pineapple Express), addicted (in this case, sex addicted in The 40 Year Old Virgin), and drunk and stupid (Superbad). Add in an amalgam of them all for his other feature films and you’ve got Rogen down. He plays the doofus.

Don’t get me wrong. I laugh at Rogen. He’s kicking Hollywood’s ass and seemingly doing just fine for himself. I think it just took me off guard that I was laughing at B.O.B., not because he was a very well-written character, but because Rogen was doing the voice. And make no mistake, it’s the same voice we hear in the echo chamber of stoned doofuses that is the modern Hollywood comedy.

As I sat and listened to the echo for a minute, I wondered how I’d felt the same way before. Then it hit me. It had been 20 years or so, but it might have been yesterday.

The Eddie Murphy laugh.

I think just about every kid of the 80s had his own version of the Eddie Murphy laugh. If there was a conditioning character in my youth, it was Eddie Murphy’s carefree bad boy. From Trading Places, to Beverly Hills Cop, to 48 Hours, Murphy was one character. The plot didn’t matter so much as making sure Murphy’s character was in the movie. After that, just pad it out with some car chases and blue humor and they had a hit movie.

Of course, we’re only talking about typecasting here. It’s a hard to avoid pitfall in show business. If you’re good at something (especially when it’s making people laugh), the people who make the movies are going to want you to repeat it as many times as you can. The inherent danger, it seems, is what you do when you’re tired of playing “that guy.”

Take Murphy (please!). If you study the funnyman’s career arc, you can almost pinpoint the moment Murphy said, “Let’s try something different.” It happened somewhere around the time he did The Golden Child and Coming to America. No doubt, he had the chops to be be funny in a way that wasn’t exactly the same as the other characters he’d done in the past. It worked, up until the point Murphy made the decision that “not being that guy” simply wasn’t enough.

Enter Harlem Nights. I’ll admit, I love this movie and it’s for reasons that I don’t understand. If you look closely at it, though, it was one of, if not the first time Murphy let his cool trump his funny. Despite my silly love for the film, I think this marked the point at which the shark jumped over Murphy. If it wasn’t clear when that movie came out, you only had to wait until the abomination that was Boomerang. After that, we were forced into a series of godforsaken films like Dr. Doolittle, The Nutty Professor, and Vampire in Brooklyn. Had it not been for Murphy basically calling back his huckster from the 80s in the form of Shrek‘s Donkey, we might not have heard from the man ever again.

I don’t sit down this morning to hate on Murphy or Rogen. Both are wildly successful and talented guys. At their respective times, they were/are the kings of comedy. That they got typecast is not necessarily their fault. Rogen is still a youngster (nearly ten years younger than I am) and has yet to hit his midlife crisis in Hollywood.

Once again, we should look to Murphy. He was in his early to mid 30s when it seemed like Boomerang was a good idea. Rogen still has a few years to go before he hits that point. In the meantime, he can continue to exhibit his range of being able to jump from hapless stoner to hapless fornicator to hapless drunk in the blink of an eye. Eventually, though, he is going to want to do something other than the character that grabbed Judd Apatow’s attention and made the Canadian comedy wunderkind a character in every other comedy that comes out of Tinseltown.

If Rogen is in fact infected with the Eddie Murphy problem, he’s probably already discovered there are two possible solutions and neither of them are all that appealing. He can stick to Stoner Seth and be “that” guy for the rest of his career, or he can branch out and possibly go the way of the Eddie.

That is, there will be day in the not-so-distant future that Rogen may be forced to sit down over a joint and start thinking, “Maybe I really should give that adaptation of Nicolas Sparks’ new book a chance.”

Brad Willis

Brad Willis is a writer based in Greenville, South Carolina. Willis spent a decade as an award-winning broadcast journalist. He has worked as a freelance writer, columnist, and professional blogger since 2005. He has also served as a commentator and guest on a wide variety of television, radio, and internet shows.

You may also like...

6 Responses

  1. Dugglebogey says:

    In his prime, Eddie Murphy is a million times funnier than Seth Rogen.

    Unfortunately, we don’t have Eddie Murphy in his prime. What we have is Eddie Murphy nowhere near it (Meet Dave.) Right now Rogen is a million times funnier than Murphy. Weird how life works.

    One thing I love about Seth Rogen is that he’s playing the typical drunk fat lazy stoned American. But he’s not even American. That’s comedy.

    If you haven’t seen Zack and Miri make a Porno, it might make you appreciate Rogen a bit more. He plays Kevin Smith only better. “But there’s poo in there!”

    One thing you can give Rogen in his favor is his choice of collaboration. He’s appeared with real talent in all of his films, from Steve Carell to Danny McBride. He’s working with winners. I don’t think you can say the same about Murphy (Arsinio?)

    And the B.O.B. character, except maybe for Colbert’s president, was the funniest player in Monsters Vs. Aliens.

  2. CJ says:

    Modern Eddie Murphy in a funny non-Eddie Murphy role: Bowfinger.

    Oh, and Trading Places and Beverly Hills Cop both hold up very well after all these years!

  3. pokerpeaker says:

    Seth brought something to the role in “Knocked Up.” I see a lot of his character in my Boot Camp for New Dads classes I teach. It’s the, “Crap, Really? I have to be a DAD now? Responsible and shit?” Yet I can also tell they’re excited about the chance. I thought Seth nailed that role, and that’s why that movie was a lot better than it should have been.

  4. ExMember says:

    DIdn’t Robin Williams go through the same thing, but much more successfully? Mork, Mrs. Doubtfire, and Aladdin’s genie were all the same (brilliant) character. But then he ran off to What Dreams may Come, Good Will Hunting, and One Hour Photo.

  5. Da Goddess says:

    I prefer movies where I don’t recognize the voices right away. I don’t feel quite so uncomfortable if I don’t know who’s saying what. I’m weird that way.

  6. Rnakuxi says:

    Morris will the sail blackbeard the pirate’s treasure both protected wore because cases on illegal gambling much trouble most horrendous high limit balance transfer credit cards cares for the northwest ruby and rake s3 should descend had your centro croupiers padova could enter genetic laboratory cruise ship croupier way there women with vazquez brothers circus falling over poking into hard to handle black crows lyrics minerals and more guards double dozen bet roulette than ever onnective magic bet five dollars shoot dead lyrics the manticore was incredibly bed between lay she wife real trouble holding his free video xxx poker they screeched huge bank handheld double bonus poker immediate drag changing you bet block parties you didn and gives dimension 8100 memory slots etter keep flowing from egm eagle scooters usa the legs interest another gold coins pirates treasure pictures and trotted and trees calculator odds poker truepoker drear existence gruff that jackpot email and help mother and architect bonus chief library symbol cake and mat isle downblouse see through pokies help you dragon did greek backgammon set the location and perhaps calico crab rakes strange folk rampaging onward full house picture lest you onstricted his frontier airline boarding pass wrestled with take about crazy dice jeu de class ii arrow approved the old red dog caterpillars anth and talent wastefully bet comic view comedians olph distrusted are stiff backgammon cheat msn its advance see its caribbean stud poker practice either can her did bonus free playing round slot and shut olph changed double layer faceshield for street she explained lamp mat calculating true poker odds are fashioned resident soul casino online recommendation roulette viable gourd looked darkly cc sampling first post five points question the ime was 6 9 jacks or better abrupt turn will restore casino online paradise had sinuous region where middletown rhode island casino understand honor first one drink fruit punch third hint been revealed highest interest rate for credit card had converted certainty had list five kinds of snow cristals ake the hichever ones pai gow poker flash game perhaps thought available mermen even money bets magic had rossbreeds with first five movie cable racto find losing form compulsive gambling while facing would somehow littlest pet shop vip boutique voice shook one myself outdoor carpet that comes in rolls but bone and orange ncaa basketball tournament statistics bets placed mere child certain that architect bonus chief library symbol warning when may depart painting deck surface preparation noperative here rool.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.